Ripe time to consider removing all types of reservations except for those who are financially backward and really need it.
Brig K.G.Behl(Retd)
President All India Consumers Council, Uttarakhand
The latest demand by the richest community in the country (Patels) for reservation of seats for them and other communities too who are well off, has created an awakening amongst the people that reservation of seats for different communities has out lived its utility and needs to be revised in the interest of the country and the poorer sections of the society who really need it and to whom the benefits of reservation are not reaching, especially at grass root level.
Benefits of Reservation of seats have never reached the majority of the people for whom those were meant except for a few belonging to the creamy layer, who were already self sufficient. Such people exploited the situation for their own good and improved their position and became leaders and financially better than their unreserved counter parts. They totally forgot about the reserved class from where they came from or represented. Some of those even tried to remove their reservation tag once it became useless to provide them any further benefits. Reservations, where ever made, have initially lead to exploitations and later to humiliations to the extent that people in that class started hating if some one called them of that class as they stood up at their own and reached that standard without any additional concession or aid as the intended benefits never reached them, especially at grass root level and detest being called of that category. They prefer to compete with others and take open seats rather than any reserved seats.
The Constitution of India made provision for certain reservations to uplift various sections of the society who had been neglected for different reasons and needed assistance for strengthening those and bringing them at par with other sections, so that the society may function smoothly as one body without any distinction or discrimination. It is here that some sections of the society were provided certain reservations, for limited times, so that they may come up and join the main stream. But unluckily the advantage of these reservation benefits, which are meant for weaker people are taken away by the affluent persons in those weaker section, who are already well up, and do not reach the people whom it is proposed to assist to make them rise. When the desired benefits did not reach the persons for whom those were meant year after year it was decided to remove the creamy layer from those sections and devoid them of the benefits so that it reaches others but that too failed as this creamy layer had spread too far and penetration through that become difficult.
The only way left is to provide benefits to all, poorer sections of all communities who deserve those without making any reservation of seats etc for only limited communities. It has been observed that even at those places where people from lower strata have been placed in reserved seats benefits have not accrued either to them or their section of the society as other affluent persons of that section have dictated them and reaped the benefits to themselves- causing a ridiculous situation leading to misuse of the benefits and causing imbalance in other sections who are had been denied of those benefits. Some of them have amassed so much of wealth that the other sections of the society, now look poorer in comparison with those and feeling has been generated that they need help and not the ones whom the benefits have been provided.
. The glaring example is our great leader Bharat Ratna Dr.Bhim Rao Ambedkar, who with his talent and assistance from philanthropists, rose that high, without any reservation. Of course he needed help/assistance which he got. Similarly assistance should be given to all those who need to develop their talent and not reservation to enjoy benefits at others cost.
Time has come to reconsider the whole system of reservation whether it is for scheduled caste/ Scheduled Tribes, OBCs or even women – as lately they have shown that given better facilities and opportunities they are no less than men. Assistance is, thus, required by all types of classes whose income is less than a certain limit and with that assistance they will be in a position to achieve standards set for normal people. Once they come and join the normal stream they can take up any competition and achieve same or rather better results than their normal counterparts. It will not lower the standards but rather generate a healthy competition to achieve better results.
It will be in the fitness of things if the Prime Minister calls a meeting of all heads of major Political Parties of the country to decide this delicate issue which is going beyond proportions and needs a major operation to bring the country to a healthy situation. They should then call a special session of Parliament to amend the Constitution and settle this issue once for all.
Comments are closed.