Composite and mixed supply traders face confusion of rates after GST claims expert
GST has been launched 10 days back with much fanfare, however the confusion regarding its various categorization still persist in the market.
Chairman of Federation of Industrialist Traders and Jewellers Association president Sushil Jain gave his views and suggestions on this confusion which has popped up after implementation of GST.
He said, “GST council should clear the confusing law of composite supply and Mixed supply, in market the confusion seems to be very high”
Difference between Composite Supply and Mixed Supply
Business community is too much confuse to make bills of product. Difference between Composite and Mixed Supply under GST Law is not very clear alothough the general definition of the two can be understood as below:
- Composite supply is one where 2 or more goods or services are supplied together, in a natural bundle and in a normal course of business, provided one of which is a principal supply. The composite supply is taxed at the rate applicable to the principal supply.
- Mixed supply is one which which does not satisfies the meaning of composite supply. The mixed supply is taxed at the rate which is the highest among all the supplies provided in a mixed bundle.
Details of Norm :
1)Composite Supply; Any supply of goods or services will be treated as composite supply if it fulfills all the following criteria simultaneously:
a) Supply of 2 or more goods or services together.
ii)Its a natural bundle, as even if you don’t opt for food, no deduction in price would be there, and
iii)Transportation of Passenger satisfies the criteria of principal/main service in the above definition.
2)Mixed Supply: Any bundle of goods or services provided together which is not a composite supply will be treated as mixed supply. Thus what is important to understand and remember is the meaning of composite supply. An illustration of mixed supply of goods or services is:
When we buy fruit basket for any ceremonious occasion, it usually consist of fruits, aerated drinks, canned juices, chocolates, dry fruits etc. These all individual components can also be sold separately at the rate applicable to each of them. Now when these all components are sold together the issue arises at what rate the seller shall charge tax. Now is this a composite supply or mixed supply? For seeking an answer, we shall see fulfillment of all the conditions as stipulated in the definition of composite supply.
a) Supply of 2 or more goods or services together; Fulfilled
b) In a natural bundle i.e., goods or services are usually provided together in normal course of business; NOT FULFILLED(as they can be sold separately too)
c) One of the good or service in such natural bundle shall be the principal/main service. NOT FULFILLED(as they can be sold separately too)
Thus since all the conditions are not satisfied the above illustration is an instance of mixed supply and not composite supply.
Rate of Tax at which Composite Supply/Mixed Supply shall be charged to tax:
In case of composite supply, rate of tax applicable to the principal supply will be charged to the whole composite bundle. That is rate of GST applicable to transportation of passengers by rail will be charged by IRCTC on the booking of Shatabdi ticket.
In case of mixed supply, that rate of tax will be applicable, which is the highest among all the items of a mixed supply. In our example the rate of tax which is the highest among all the items(fruits, aerated drinks, canned juices, chocolates, dry fruits) will apply.
Sushil Kumar Jain, Chairman of FEDERATION OF INDUSTRIALIST TRADERS AND JEWELERS ASSOCIATIONS says, “we request the GST council to clear the items which comes into composite or mixed at an earliest”.